| National Fastpitch Coaches
Association |
| 2012 (Atlantic) |
| Tori Higginbotham, SO, OF |
First |
| Kristina Karagiorgis, FY, P |
First |
| Jaclyn Quinn, SR, U |
Second |
| Kelly Keys, SO, 2B |
Second |
| 2011 (Atlantic) |
|
| MacKenzie Creech, FY, P |
Second |
| Jaclyn Quinn, JR, C |
Third |
| Torri Higginbotham, FY, OF |
Third |
| 2010 (Atlantic) |
|
| Kristy White, SR, 2B |
First |
| Brittaney Brown, SR, P |
First |
| Jaclyn Quinn, SO, C |
Second |
| 2009 (Atlantic) |
|
| Kristy White, JR, 2B |
Second |
| 2008 (Atlantic) |
|
| Mandy Nixon, SR, OF |
First |
| Brittaney Brown, SO, P |
Third |
| 2006 (Atlantic) |
| Mandy Nixon, SO, OF |
Second |
| 2001 (South) |
| Shelley Wineken, SO, 2B |
First |
| Nikki Rowe, SO, DH |
First |
| Kelly Lupton, SR, OF |
Second |
| 2000 (South) |
| Kelly Lupton, OF |
First |
| 1989 (Mid-Atlantic) |
| Judy Muhr, OF |
Second |
| 1986 (Mid-Atlantic) |
| Susan Sigler, C |
Second |
| Amy Simpson, 1B |
Second |
